Insurance company claim contact directory

COLUMBUS (June 13, 2013) – To assist Ohioans with filing claims from recent storms, the Ohio Insurance Institute (OII) provides this partial list of insurance company contact resources. Some insurers may begin to assemble catastrophe teams and/or field representatives in the storm-damaged area to expedite the claims process. Companies will also process claims through their local agencies and offices, by email or electronically through their Web sites. Policyholders can either contact their local agent during normal business hours or use the toll-free numbers and Web information below. For companies not listed, contact OII at 614-228-1593.

Company Toll-free claims number Website for filing claims
Allied 800-282-1446
Allstate 800-547-8676
American Family Insurance 800-692-6326
Buckeye Insurance Group 800-672-3558
Central Insurance 888-263-2924
Century Insurance Group 800-825-9489
Cincinnati Insurance 877-242-2544
EMC-Hamilton Mutual 888-362-2255
Erie Insurance 800-367-3743
Farmers Insurance 888-425-2467
FCCI Insurance Group 800-226-3224
Frankenmuth 800-234-4433
GEICO 800-861-8380
German Mutual 800-597-0140
Grange Insurance 800-445-3030
Grinnell Mutual 877-467-2252
Hanover/Citizens 800-628-0250
Marion Mutual 800-222-3873 X1; Eve: Same, then X8
Mennonite Mutual 800-678-6885
Miami Mutual/Celina 800-231-2318
Motorists Insurance 800-876-8766
Nationwide 800-421-3535
Ohio Mutual 888-895-7725
Progressive Insurance 800-776-4737
State Auto 800-766-1853
State Farm 800-732-5246
USAA 800-531-8722
Washington Mutual 800-222-3873 X1; Eve: Same, then X8
Wayne Mutual 800-222-3873 X1; Eve: Same, then X8
Western Reserve Group 800-362-0426
Westfield Companies 866-937-2663


 And OII compiled some tips when filing an insurance claim.